Loading...

Share Buyback Valuation Services | Virtual Auditor

Quick answer: Unlisted share buybacks under Section 68 of the Companies Act require a defensible fair-value determination for the board and shareholders. Since 1 October 2024, buyback proceeds are taxed as deemed dividends in shareholders' hands — replacing the company-level buyback tax — making price-setting and shareholder-level planning inseparable from the valuation.

Valuation for share buyback under Section 68 Companies Act. Fair value determination, SEBI buyback regulations, tax implications. IBBI Registered Valuer.

Last reviewed: July 2026 by CA V. Viswanathan (FCA, ACS, CFE, IBBI Registered Valuer)

Section 68 Buyback — the Conditions That Decide Whether You Can Buy at All

A buyback is not simply a company purchasing its own shares; it is a capital transaction hemmed in by Section 68 of the Companies Act, 2013, and a wrong step voids the whole exercise. The gateway conditions we test before any valuation is commissioned: the buyback must be authorised by the articles; it can only be funded out of free reserves, the securities premium account, or the proceeds of a fresh issue (never the proceeds of an earlier issue of the same kind of shares); the aggregate bought back in a financial year cannot exceed 25% of paid-up capital plus free reserves; the equity bought back in any year cannot exceed 25% of paid-up equity capital; and the post-buyback debt-to-equity ratio must not exceed 2:1. Only fully paid shares qualify, the buyback must complete within one year of the authorising resolution, and a further issue of the same kind of shares is barred for six months afterwards.

RouteApproval neededCeiling
Board routeBoard resolution onlyUp to 10% of paid-up equity capital + free reserves
Shareholder routeSpecial resolutionUp to 25% of paid-up capital + free reserves (25% of equity for equity)

The paperwork trail — a solvency declaration in Form SH-9 signed by two directors, the return of buyback in Form SH-11, and the mandatory extinguishment of bought-back shares within seven days — all rests on a defensible price. That is where the valuation sits.

Why Unlisted Buybacks Need a Registered-Valuer Price

For an unlisted company there is no market quotation to anchor the offer, so the buyback price must be established by valuation. A price pitched too high transfers value from continuing shareholders to the exiting ones (and can strip reserves below the solvency line); a price too low shortchanges the exiting shareholder and invites an oppression complaint. Our buyback valuations set a fair value using a blend of DCF, comparable-company multiples and net-asset value appropriate to the company's stage, and we document the workings so the board's SH-9 solvency view and the auditor's sign-off both stand on the same number. Where the buyback is from specific shareholders (an exit or a promoter consolidation) rather than a pro-rata offer to all, the fairness of the price to the remaining shareholders becomes the central question — and the valuation file is the board's defence.

The October 2024 Tax Shift — Read This Before You Price

The economics of buybacks changed fundamentally for any buyback where consideration is paid on or after 1 October 2024. The old regime taxed the company at roughly 23% (Section 115QA) and left the receipt tax-free in the shareholder's hands. That is gone. Now the entire buyback consideration is treated as a deemed dividend in the shareholder's hands under Section 2(22)(f), taxed at the shareholder's slab rate, with no deduction for the cost of the shares against that dividend. Instead, the cost of acquisition is treated as a capital loss that the shareholder can carry forward and set off against other capital gains.

The practical consequences are sharp: a high-slab resident or a foreign shareholder without treaty relief can face a far heavier burden than under the old 115QA regime, while the capital loss may be of little use to a shareholder with no offsetting gains. This flips the buyback-versus-alternatives arithmetic for many closely held companies, and the valuation exercise must now be run alongside a shareholder-level tax model — not after it.

Buyback vs Dividend vs Capital Reduction — Choosing the Right Instrument

  1. Dividend: now taxed at slab in the shareholder's hands (post-2020 abolition of DDT), simple to declare, no capital-account restrictions — but it does not reduce the share count or return capital selectively.
  2. Buyback: returns capital and reduces the share base (useful for EPS, promoter consolidation, or funding an exit), but post-October-2024 the deemed-dividend treatment removes its former tax edge and Section 68's ceilings constrain quantum.
  3. Capital reduction under Section 66: an NCLT-sanctioned route with no 25% ceiling, capable of returning surplus capital or extinguishing accumulated losses, useful where buyback limits bite — but it carries deemed-dividend consequences to the extent of accumulated profits and a longer tribunal timeline.

We model all three side by side, at the shareholder level, so the board chooses on after-tax outcomes rather than gross headline value.

Process, Timelines and the Pitfalls We See Most

A buyback is a sequence of dated steps, and slipping any one of them can invalidate the whole exercise or attract penalty. The recurring mistakes we are called in to prevent:

  • Reserve miscalculation: treating securities premium or revaluation reserve as "free reserves" for the 25% ceiling — revaluation reserves do not count, and using the wrong base overstates the permissible quantum.
  • Debt-equity breach: failing to test the post-buyback debt-to-equity ratio against the 2:1 limit, so a leveraged company finds the buyback impermissible only after committing to it.
  • Missed extinguishment: not physically destroying the bought-back share certificates within seven days of completion, a distinct compliance default.
  • Cooling-off ignored: issuing the same kind of shares within six months of the buyback, or launching a fresh buyback before the twelve-month gap, both of which are barred.
  • Stale valuation: pricing the offer on an old valuation while the company's position has moved, undermining both the solvency declaration and fairness to continuing shareholders.

We sequence the resolutions, the SH-8 letter of offer, the SH-9 solvency declaration, the payout and the SH-11 return against a single calendar, with the fair-value opinion refreshed to the offer date so the whole chain rests on a current number.

Our Buyback Valuation Deliverables and Fees

A typical engagement delivers a fair-value opinion for the buyback price, a solvency-support note aligned to Form SH-9, a shareholder-level tax comparison of buyback versus dividend versus capital reduction, and coordination with the company secretary on SH-8/SH-9/SH-11. Draft valuation within 4–6 working days of a complete information pack.

ServiceFee (from)
Buyback fair-value report (single class, board route)₹30,000
Buyback valuation + shareholder tax comparison₹45,000
Selective/promoter buyback with fairness note₹60,000+
Capital-reduction (Sec 66) valuation supportScoped per matter

Why Choose Virtual Auditor?

  • Fellow Chartered Accountant (FCA) with 14+ years experience
  • IBBI Registered Valuer (IBBI/RV/03/2019/12333)
  • Certified Fraud Examiner (CFE)
  • Associate Company Secretary (ACS)
  • Offices in Chennai, Bangalore, and Mumbai
  • 100+ complex valuations completed

Our Approach

We combine deep regulatory expertise with AI-powered tools to deliver accurate, defensible, and timely results. Every engagement is led by CA V. Viswanathan, ensuring senior-level attention.

Contact Us

Chennai (HQ): G-131, Ground Floor, Phase 3, Spencer Plaza Mall, Anna Salai, Chennai 600002. Phone: +91 99622 60333.

Bangalore: 7th Floor, Mahalakshmi Chambers, 29, MG Road, Bangalore 560001. Phone: +91 95139 39333.

Mumbai: Workafella, AK Estate, SV Road, Goregaon West, Mumbai 400062. Phone: +91 77000 89597.

Strategic Business & Compliance Insights

Frequently Asked Questions

How is the buyback price of an unlisted company determined?
There is no market quote for unlisted shares, so the price is fixed by valuation. A registered valuer arrives at fair value using a stage-appropriate blend of discounted cash flow, comparable-company multiples and net-asset value. The board relies on that number for its solvency declaration in Form SH-9 and for demonstrating fairness to the shareholders who remain after the buyback. A documented valuation file is what protects the directors if the price is later challenged as favouring exiting shareholders.
How is a share buyback taxed after 1 October 2024?
The regime changed completely. For consideration paid on or after 1 October 2024, Section 115QA company-level buyback tax is withdrawn, and the entire buyback consideration is treated as a deemed dividend in the shareholder's hands under Section 2(22)(f), taxed at slab rates with no deduction for the cost of shares. The acquisition cost instead becomes a capital loss available for set-off against other capital gains. For high-slab or foreign shareholders this is often costlier than the old regime, so price and tax must be modelled together.
What are the main conditions under Section 68 for a buyback?
The company must be authorised by its articles; the buyback must be funded only from free reserves, the securities premium account or proceeds of a fresh issue; the annual buyback cannot exceed 25% of paid-up capital plus free reserves (and 25% of paid-up equity for equity shares); the post-buyback debt-equity ratio must not exceed 2:1; only fully paid shares qualify; and the exercise must complete within one year. A board-only route is available up to 10% of paid-up equity capital plus free reserves; beyond that a special resolution is required.
What is the difference between the board route and the shareholder route?
A board resolution alone can authorise a buyback of up to 10% of paid-up equity capital plus free reserves in a year. Anything above that, up to the 25% ceiling, requires a special resolution passed by shareholders. The board route is faster and suits small capital returns; the special-resolution route is used for larger buybacks, promoter consolidation or funding a significant exit. Both require the Form SH-9 solvency declaration and Form SH-11 return, and both need a defensible valuation behind the price.
Is a buyback better than paying a dividend?
Since October 2024 the historic tax advantage of buybacks has largely disappeared, because buyback proceeds are now taxed as deemed dividends in the shareholder's hands just like an actual dividend. A buyback still has non-tax merits — it returns capital selectively, reduces the share count and can support EPS or a promoter's consolidation — but the choice should be driven by an after-tax, shareholder-level comparison of dividend, buyback and capital reduction rather than by a presumed tax saving that no longer exists.
Can a company buy back shares from only some shareholders?
Yes — a buyback can be from the open market, from odd-lot holders, or from specific shareholders on a negotiated basis (common for exits or promoter consolidation). A selective buyback raises the sharpest fairness question, because value must not be transferred unfairly from continuing shareholders to the exiting ones. Here the valuation must not only fix a fair exit price but also demonstrate that the price is fair to those who remain, and the board should hold a fairness note supporting the transaction.
What documents and filings does a buyback require?
Board and, where needed, shareholder approval; an explanatory statement; a letter of offer in Form SH-8; a solvency declaration in Form SH-9 signed by two directors; completion of the buyback within one year; extinguishment and physical destruction of the bought-back shares within seven days of completion; and the return of buyback in Form SH-11 within thirty days. A separate bank account for the buyback and a bar on further same-kind issues for six months also apply. Every one of these rests on the fair-value figure the valuation establishes.