FCA  |  ACS  |  CFE  |  IBBI/RV/03/2019/12333✉ support@virtualauditor.in✆ +91 99622 60333
Valuation

Valuation Consultants

Virtual AuditorPublished: 26 May 2023🕒 7 min readLast updated: 7 Nov 2026

Who may sign what

PurposeLawWho must sign
Preferential allotment, related-party asset deals, mergers, minority buy-outs, winding upCompanies Act, 2013 ss.62(1)(c), 192, 230–232, 236, 281; s.247IBBI Registered Valuer in the relevant asset class
Fair value and liquidation value in insolvencyInsolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016; CIRP and Liquidation RegulationsTwo IBBI Registered Valuers appointed by the resolution professional
Price of shares issued to, or bought from, a non-residentFEM (Non-debt Instruments) Rules, 2019, rule 21Chartered Accountant, SEBI-registered merchant banker or practising cost accountant
Fair market value of ESOP shares for the perquisite on exerciseIncome-tax Rules, 1962 rule 3(8)(iii) (2026 Rules rule 15(6)(d))SEBI-registered merchant banker
Fair value of options at grant for the expenseInd AS 102 / AS and the ICAI guidance noteNo statutory signatory; the auditor will expect a reasoned report, usually from a registered valuer or a CA
Purchase price allocation, impairment, financial instrumentsInd AS 103, 36, 109 and 113No statutory signatory; auditors look for a valuer following ICAI Valuation Standards
US stock options for a US parentInternal Revenue Code s.409AAn independent appraiser; no Indian statutory category

The practical consequence: a funding round from a foreign investor needs a registered valuer's report for the Companies Act leg and a FEMA certificate for the RBI leg. A consultant who holds only one of those signatures will have to bring in another, and you will be paying for two engagements and reconciling two numbers.

Questions to ask before engaging a valuation consultant

  1. Which registration are you signing under? Ask for the IBBI registration number and asset class, or the SEBI merchant banker registration, or the ICAI membership and certificate of practice number — and check each on the regulator's site. Our registered valuer guide explains how.
  2. Can you cover every leg of this transaction? If not, who signs the rest, and will the two reports reconcile?
  3. Which standard will the report follow? The answer should be the ICAI Valuation Standards, 2018 or another named international standard, not "accepted principles".
  4. Show me a sample report. Look for the rule 8(3) items in order — purpose, dates, sources, procedures, major factors, conclusion — and for a sensitivity section. Our valuation report guide is the checklist.
  5. How do you test the projections? A valuer who takes management's numbers as given and disclaims them is not doing the job rule 8 describes.
  6. How is the discount rate built? Expect a build-up with named sources, not a single asserted rate.
  7. Who signs? Under section 247 the registered valuer signs in person with the registration number. A report issued in a firm's name only is not a registered valuer's report.
  8. What is the turnaround from a complete data room, and what is a complete data room? A clear list of inputs is a sign the consultant has done this before.
  9. What is the fee, and what is outside it? Filings (PAS-3, FC-GPR), government fees and any second valuer are usually separate.
  10. Will you stand behind the number? Ask whether the valuer will answer questions from the investor's analysts, the auditor or the Registrar.

Warning signs

  • A fee quoted before the purpose, the share classes and the valuation date are known
  • A report with no valuation date, or with one date for appointment, valuation and report
  • Disclaimers that shift responsibility for the conclusion to the client — rule 8(3)(l) and the IBBI's 2020 guidelines do not allow them
  • A conclusion that matches the term sheet exactly with no reconciliation shown
  • A FEMA certificate offered as if it were a Companies Act report, or the reverse
  • No sensitivity analysis — the reader cannot tell how much of the value rests on one assumption

How our reports are built and reviewed

This practice issues registered valuer reports through V. Viswanathan (IBBI/RV/03/2019/12333, Securities or Financial Assets) and FEMA and tax certificates as a Chartered Accountant with a UDIN, so a round with a foreign investor is handled as one engagement with one model and two signatures. Every report is built on a financial model with a tax schedule that carries losses forward, a discount rate built up from named sources, and a validation layer — sensitivity tables, a tornado ranking of drivers, a 10,000-run Monte Carlo simulation, the Chaffe model for marketability discounts and a breakeven test on the revenue ramp. Before signing, the report is checked against the rule 8(3) list item by item, the arithmetic is re-performed from the inputs, and the purposes and restrictions on use are read back against the engagement letter.

Fees are quoted on scope. The ESOP valuation per grant date and the FEMA valuation certificate are listed on the ESOP valuation and FEMA valuation pages; the pricing page carries the current schedule; and the valuation services page describes the eighteen methods and twelve validation tools we draw on.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a registered valuer, a merchant banker and a Chartered Accountant for valuation?

The law assigns each a role. An IBBI Registered Valuer signs valuations the Companies Act or the Insolvency Code requires (s.247). A SEBI-registered merchant banker determines the ESOP perquisite value under rule 3(8)(iii) of the Income-tax Rules. A Chartered Accountant, merchant banker or practising cost accountant certifies FEMA pricing under rule 21 of the NDI Rules. One transaction can need two of these.

Can a Chartered Accountant sign a valuation for a preferential allotment?

Only if the CA is also registered with the IBBI as a valuer for Securities or Financial Assets. Section 247 of the Companies Act and rule 13 of the Share Capital and Debentures Rules require a registered valuer; a CA's certificate on its own is not enough.

How much does a valuation consultant charge in India?

It depends on the purpose, the number of share classes and the regimes the report must serve, so a fee quoted before those are known is a warning sign. Our FEMA certificate and ESOP valuation fees are listed on the respective service pages and the pricing page; Companies Act reports are quoted on scope.

What should I check in a sample valuation report?

That the twelve rule 8(3) items are present and in order, that the valuation standard is named, that the discount rate is built up from sourced inputs, that discounts are shown separately, that there is a sensitivity analysis, and that caveats explain limitations rather than disclaim responsibility.

Who signs a registered valuer's report?

The registered valuer personally, with the IBBI registration number and asset class and the date of the report. A report issued only in a firm's name does not satisfy section 247.

Author: CA V. Viswanathan, FCA, ACS, CFE, IBBI Registered Valuer (IBBI/RV/03/2019/12333). Last reviewed 7 Nov 2026.

📞💬