CA for CIT(A) Appeal in India: Who Can Represent You
Last updated: 18 Nov 2026
Quick Answer: A CA for a CIT(A) appeal is a chartered accountant in practice who prepares and argues your first income-tax appeal. Section 288 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 lists who may act as authorised representative: a chartered accountant, an advocate and certain others. Any taxpayer with an adverse assessment, penalty or demand order can appoint one, or appear in person.
Who may represent a taxpayer before the Commissioner (Appeals) under section 288, what a chartered accountant does in a first appeal, and how to choose one.
What does a CA for a CIT(A) appeal do, and who needs one?
A first appeal against an income-tax order goes to the Joint Commissioner (Appeals) or the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals), written CIT(A). The law lets you run it yourself or through an authorised representative. A chartered accountant in practice is one of the persons the Act names for that role.
You need one when an order adds income, disallows a claim, raises a demand or levies a penalty and you want the grounds, evidence and submissions prepared professionally. This page covers who may represent you, what the CA does and how to choose. Forms, fee slabs and procedure are in our detailed guide:
Who can represent a taxpayer before the Commissioner (Appeals)?
Section 250(2) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 gives the appellant the right to be heard in person or by an authorised representative. Section 288 says who that can be. The person must be authorised by you in writing and must be one of these:
- A relative, or a person regularly employed by you
- An officer of a scheduled bank with which you keep a current account or have other regular dealings
- A legal practitioner entitled to practise in any civil court in India
- An accountant, meaning a chartered accountant under the Chartered Accountants Act, 1949 who holds a valid certificate of practice
- A person with an accountancy examination recognised by the Board, or educational qualifications it has prescribed
Section 288(1) has one exception: where you are required under section 131 to attend personally to be examined on oath or affirmation, a representative cannot attend in your place.
Sub-sections (4) and (5) of section 288 bar some persons, including an insolvent, a person convicted of an offence involving fraud (for ten years), and a legal practitioner or accountant found guilty of professional misconduct, to the extent of the disciplinary order.
CA, advocate or self-representation: what does the statute say?
The Act does not rank the representatives. A chartered accountant and an advocate have the same right of appearance before the first appellate authority, and a taxpayer may also appear alone.
| Option | Basis in the Income-tax Act, 1961 | Points to weigh |
|---|---|---|
| Chartered accountant in practice | Section 288(2)(iv) and the Explanation defining accountant | Works from the accounts, the return and the computation; suits appeals that turn on facts, books and evidence |
| Advocate | Section 288(2)(iii) | Suits appeals that turn mainly on a question of law or that are likely to go on to the High Court |
| Self, relative or regular employee | Section 250(2) and section 288(2)(i) | No professional fee; you carry the drafting, the limitation dates and the portal replies yourself |
Many appeals raise both facts and law.
What does a chartered accountant do in a first appeal, step by step?
- Reads the order and your replies, and lists what can be appealed under section 246A
- Fixes the last date. Section 249(2) gives 30 days, from service of the notice of demand for an assessment or penalty, and from service of the intimation of the order in other cases
- If the date has passed, drafts the condonation request. Section 249(3) allows a late appeal for sufficient cause; it is discretionary
- Checks the tax-paid condition in section 249(4): tax due on the returned income, or an amount equal to the advance tax payable where no return was filed
- Drafts the statement of facts and the grounds of appeal, each error as a separate numbered ground
- Prepares Form 35 on the e-filing portal with the fee details under section 249(1). The taxpayer e-verifies it from the taxpayer's own login
- Prepares a stay application to the Assessing Officer, who has a discretion under section 220(6) while the appeal is pending. This is a separate engagement
- Files written submissions and replies electronically under the Faceless Appeal Scheme, 2021, where it applies
- Applies to admit additional evidence, showing which of the four situations in Rule 46A(1) applies
- Requests a personal hearing where needed. Under the 2021 Scheme it is held by video conference
- Explains the risk before filing: under section 251 the authority can confirm, reduce, enhance or annul an assessment
What documents should you hand over to the CA?
- The order appealed against and the notice of demand, with proof of the date each was served
- Assessment notices and your replies
- The return, computation and financial statements for the year
- Form 26AS and the Annual Information Statement
- Books, bank statements and agreements on the disputed items
- Challans for tax already paid
- A written authorisation in favour of the representative, as section 288(2) requires
- Access to the income-tax e-filing account
Income-tax Act, 1961 and Income-tax Act, 2025: which provision applies?
The Income-tax Act, 2025 applies from 1 April 2026 for tax year 2026-27 onward. Earlier years stay under the 1961 Act. The table maps only the provisions read on 18 November 2026. Sections 359 and 360 were read on a reproduction of the 2025 Act; the others on the Income Tax Department's website.
| Subject | Income-tax Act, 1961 | Income-tax Act, 2025 |
|---|---|---|
| Orders appealable to the Joint Commissioner (Appeals) | Section 246 | Section 356 |
| Orders appealable to the Commissioner (Appeals) | Section 246A | Section 357 |
| Form, fee, 30-day limit, condonation, tax-paid condition | Section 249 | Section 358 |
| Procedure and right to be heard | Section 250 | Section 359 |
| Powers of the appellate authority | Section 251 | Section 360 |
| Authorised representative | Section 288 | Section 515 |
| Appeal form | Form 35 (Rule 45, Income-tax Rules, 1962) | Form No. 99 (Rule 167, Income-tax Rules, 2026) |
| Additional evidence | Rule 46A (Income-tax Rules, 1962) | Rule 192 (Income-tax Rules, 2026) |
| Stay of demand; faceless appeal procedure | Section 220(6); Faceless Appeal Scheme, 2021 | The 2025 Act carries corresponding provisions |
Section 358 keeps the fee slabs, the 30-day limit, condonation for sufficient cause and the tax-paid condition. Section 515 again lists a chartered accountant holding a certificate of practice.
How to choose the best CA for a CIT(A) appeal in India
The best choice is a person whose method fits a forum that decides mostly on written material. Ask before you hire:
- Is the person who will appear a chartered accountant holding a certificate of practice, or an advocate, as section 288 requires? Ask for the membership number
- Who reads the order and drafts the grounds?
- Will you get a written view on the merits, the weak grounds and the risk of enhancement before filing?
- Is the last date worked out from the date of service and given in writing?
- Will each ground be argued separately, with page references to the evidence?
- Are the scope and the fee confirmed in writing, with stay, rectification and the second appeal priced separately?
- Can the same team carry the matter to the Tribunal?
Appeal drafting and filing is engaged and invoiced by Virtual Auditor Private Limited. Under section 288 the authorised representative is an individual, such as a chartered accountant holding a certificate of practice, whom you authorise in writing. Representation as authorised representative is by CA V. Viswanathan, FCA, of V Viswanathan & Associates, Chartered Accountants (ICAI Firm Registration No. 013713S), on your written authorisation. Documents are shared online and consultations are held by phone or video from any city in India. No outcome is guaranteed.
Fees for a CIT(A) appeal
An appeal to the CIT(A) starts from ₹25,000 + 18% GST; government fees and other charges extra. The statutory appeal fee under section 249(1) is a government fee. Stay applications, rectification and Tribunal appeals are separate engagements. To start, send the order and the notice of demand on WhatsApp to +91 99622 60333.
Primary sources
- Income-tax Act, 1961: section 288, appearance by authorised representative
- Income-tax Act, 1961: section 249, form of appeal and limitation
- Income-tax Act, 1961: section 250, procedure in appeal
- Income-tax Act, 1961: section 246A, orders appealable to the Commissioner (Appeals)
- Income-tax Act, 1961: section 246, orders appealable to the Joint Commissioner (Appeals)
- Income-tax Act, 1961: section 251, powers in appeal
- Income-tax Act, 1961: section 220, stay of demand
- Income-tax Rules, 1962: Rule 46A, additional evidence
- Faceless Appeal Scheme, 2021: Notification No. 139/2021
- Income-tax Act, 2025: section 515, appearance by authorised representative
- Income-tax Rules, 2026: Rule 167, Form No. 99
- Income-tax Rules, 2026: Rule 192, additional evidence
- Income Tax Department: Form 99 FAQs
- Income-tax e-filing portal: Form 35 user manual
Need help with this? Tell us your facts and we confirm the scope and fee in writing.
Contact Virtual Auditor Call +91-9962 260 333Frequently Asked Questions
Which is the best CA for a CIT(A) appeal in India?
The best CA for a CIT(A) appeal is one who holds a certificate of practice, reads the order personally, gives a written view on the merits before filing and argues each ground separately with evidence. Check who will actually appear and whether scope and fee are confirmed in writing. Virtual Auditor works across India on this basis; the work is led by CA V. Viswanathan, FCA. No outcome is guaranteed.
What does a CA charge for a CIT(A) appeal in India?
At Virtual Auditor, an appeal to the CIT(A) starts from ₹25,000 + 18% GST; government fees and other charges extra. The statutory appeal fee under section 249(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 is paid separately by challan. Stay applications, rectification applications and a second appeal to the Tribunal are separate engagements, and the fee is confirmed in writing before work starts.
Can Virtual Auditor handle a CIT(A) appeal for a business outside Chennai?
Yes. Form 35 is filed on the income-tax e-filing portal, and under the Faceless Appeal Scheme, 2021 notices, submissions and hearings are handled electronically, so the taxpayer's city does not matter. Virtual Auditor has offices in Chennai, Bangalore and Mumbai; documents are shared online and consultations are held by phone or video from any city in India.
Who is entitled to represent a taxpayer before the Commissioner (Appeals)?
A person authorised in writing who falls within section 288(2) of the Income-tax Act, 1961. The list includes a relative or regular employee, an officer of the taxpayer's scheduled bank, a legal practitioner, a chartered accountant holding a valid certificate of practice, and persons with accountancy or educational qualifications recognised or prescribed by the Board. The taxpayer may also appear in person under section 250(2).
Can a chartered accountant argue a CIT(A) appeal, or do I need an advocate?
A chartered accountant can. Section 288(2) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 lists both an accountant and a legal practitioner as authorised representatives, and the Act does not prefer one over the other before the first appellate authority. Choose on the nature of the dispute: facts, accounts and evidence, or mainly a question of law.
Can I file a CIT(A) appeal myself without a CA?
Yes. Section 250(2) gives the appellant the right to be heard in person, and Form 35 is filed from the taxpayer's own e-filing account. If you do it yourself you must track the 30-day limit in section 249(2), meet the tax-paid condition in section 249(4), draft the grounds and answer every notice on the portal.
Does the CA sign Form 35?
No. The CA drafts the statement of facts and the grounds, but Form 35 is filed from the taxpayer's e-filing login and e-verified by the taxpayer with a digital signature or an electronic verification code. For appeals under the Income-tax Act, 2025, Rule 167 of the Income-tax Rules, 2026 says Form No. 99 is verified by the person authorised to verify the return.
Our 30-day deadline is close. What should we send a CA first?
Send the order, the notice of demand and proof of the date on which each was served. The 30 days in section 249(2) run from that date, so it decides how much time is left. Then send the notices and replies from the assessment, the return and computation, and challans for tax paid. If the date has already passed, section 249(3) allows condonation for sufficient cause, at the discretion of the appellate authority.
Which 2025 Act section lets a CA represent me in an appeal?
Section 515 of the Income-tax Act, 2025. It corresponds to section 288 of the 1961 Act and again lists a legal practitioner and an accountant, defined as a chartered accountant holding a valid certificate of practice. The first-appeal provisions of the 2025 Act are sections 356 to 360, and the appeal form is Form No. 99 under Rule 167 of the Income-tax Rules, 2026. The 2025 Act applies from tax year 2026-27; earlier years stay under the 1961 Act.
Do I have to attend the hearing if I appoint a CA?
Usually not. Under section 288(1) an authorised representative can attend for you, except where you are required under section 131 to be examined personally on oath or affirmation. Under the Faceless Appeal Scheme, 2021 no one is required to appear in person before the appeal unit; a personal hearing, when requested, is held by video conference.
Related Services
- CIT(A) appeal services: full guide
- ITAT appeal filing in Form 36
- Income tax notice reply
- Section 270A penalty appeal
- Faceless assessment reply
About this page
Last updated: 18 Nov 2026. The practice is led by CA V. Viswanathan, FCA, ACS, CFE, IBBI Registered Valuer (IBBI/RV/03/2019/12333).